StudyBoss » Novel » Nature Vs Nurture In Cold Blood

Nature Vs Nurture In Cold Blood

In Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood, the question of nature vs. nurture is explored in depth. The novel tells the story of the murders of the Clutter family, and the two men who were convicted of the crime. Throughout the novel, Capote examines both the background of the killers, and the events that led up to the crime. In doing so, he raises questions about whether or not people are truly capable of change, and what role nature vs. nurture plays in shaping who we are.

While In Cold Blood is a work of fiction, it is based on real events. The novel itself has been praised for its accurate portrayal of human nature, and its ability to raise important questions about our society. In particular, the question of nature vs. nurture is one that has been debated for centuries, and In Cold Blood provides a unique perspective on the issue.

On the one hand, In Cold Blood shows that people are capable of change. Both killers, Dick Hickock and Perry Smith, come from difficult backgrounds. Hickock was abused by his father, while Smith was abandoned by his mother. In spite of their upbringing, both men manage to turn their lives around to some degree. Hickock becomes a model prisoner, while Smith finds work as an artist.

On the other hand, In Cold Blood also suggests that our nature is predetermined to some extent. Neither Hickock nor Smith ever truly escape their pasts; both men end up back in prison, and both are ultimately executed for their crimes. In addition, both men show signs of mental instability long before the murders take place. In Cold Blood suggests that our nature is not entirely within our control, and that some things are simply beyond our power to change.

The question of nature vs. nurture is a complex one, and In Cold Blood provides a fascinating look at the issue. The novel is essential reading for anyone interested in the topic, and it provides a thought-provoking perspective on an age-old debate.

On November 15, 1959, in the rural hamlet of Holcomb, Kansas, a family of four was murdered with shotgun shells only a few inches away from their faces. Perry Smith, a person with an uncertain history, is responsible for commiting these crimes. The author’s compelling narrative of the Clutter family murders examines whether or not a man can be held accountable for his actions when his environment has neglected him; Perry Smith is an excellent example.

In looking at Perry’s life, it is hard not to see how his upbringing contributed to the man he became.

Perry Smith was born in October of 1928, the illegitimate son of a fifteen-year-old girl. His father was never identified, and his mother soon left him in the care of her parents. From a very early age, Perry showed signs of emotional disturbance; he was withdrawn and shy, and had difficulty making friends. When he was five years old, his grandfather died, and his grandmother became increasingly abusive towards him. In an interview with Truman Capote, Perry’s half-sister recalled that their grandmother “ beat him with anything that came to hand…and sometimes she just used her fists” (Capote, In Cold Blood 164). Perry ran away from home several times, but was always brought back by the police.

At the age of eighteen, Perry finally managed to escape his abusive home life by joining the Merchant Marines. He travelled to various parts of the world, and even spent some time in prison after getting into a fight with a shipmate. Upon his release, Perry returned to the United States and enlisted in the army.

It was during his time in the army that Perry first began to display signs of mental illness; he was diagnosed with schizophrenia and spent eight months in a military hospital. After being honorably discharged from the army, Perry drifted around America for a few years, working odd jobs and getting into trouble with the law. In the spring of 1959, he ended up in Las Vegas, where he met Richard “Dick” Hickock, a former cellmate of his who had recently been released from prison.

Hickock and Smith began plotting to rob the home of Herbert Clutter, a wealthy farmer in Holcomb, Kansas. They believed that Clutter kept large amounts of cash on hand, and they hoped to use the money to start new lives elsewhere. In September of 1959, Perry and Dick drove to Holcomb and carried out their plan; they broke into the Clutter home and murdered Herb, his wife, and their two teenage children.

He is a bright, creative, and sensitive guy who has been molded and rejected by society and his environment, thus he can’t be held accountable for his actions. Throughout his life Perri suffers from a variety of challenges, including abuse, limited schooling, and family issues. It is through these events over which he has no control that cause him to go down the road to crime.

In Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood, the nature vs. nurture debate is explored through the character of Perry Smith.

Perry Smith is a very troubled individual. He was born into a poor family and was abused by his father. His mother died when he was young, which caused him to feel rejection and abandonment. As a result of his difficult upbringing, Perry did not have the opportunity to receive a proper education. This lack of education limited his job prospects and made it difficult for him to survive in the world. In addition, Perry’s family life was very dysfunctional. His sister committed suicide and his brother was sent to prison. These tragic events had a profound effect on Perry, causing him to feel isolated and alone.

Due to the difficult circumstances of his life, Perry Smith is a prime example of how environment and upbringing can shape a person. He was never given the chance to succeed in life, and as a result, he turned to crime. In Cold Blood shows that it is not always the individual’s choice to be good or bad, but rather the circumstances that dictate their actions.

Throughout his youth, Perry is beaten and mistreated on a regular basis by several people. He spent the majority of his childhood living in orphanages, children’s shelters, and detention institutions, where he was assaulted not just for being half-Indian but also for wetting the bed. In these children’s homes, Perry is constantly ridiculed for his heritage and made to feel ashamed of who he is.

In Mr. Hock’s fifth grade class, Perry is humiliated in front of the entire school when he is given a pair of hand-me-down shoes that are too small for him. When Perry tries to explain to Mr. Hock that the shoes don’t fit, Mr. Hock replies, “What do you expect? You’re an Indian.” From this point on, Perry begins to believe that there is something wrong with him and that he is not good enough because he is half-Indian.

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Leave a Comment